Putting together a weight training and fitness plan isn’t a mystery only open to fencers vying for a spot on the national team.  Lorenzo Casertano highlights the steps fencers should be taking to improve their chances on the strip:

weight training
A good weight training program will increase your power and speed

Dispelling the “Weights slow your fencing” myth

Any competitive fencer knows that strength and power play an integral part in success at the highest levels of competition. However, when it comes to how to train outside of the usual conditioning classes and drills provided by their coaches, most fencers also find themselves at a loss for what approach to take. They may have heard the weight training is bad for fencers because they might “bulk up”, or that they should only do high reps/low  weight.  Many fencers run long distances as their cardio, some run stairs, and some don’t do cardio at all.

In truth, the ideal workout plan for a fencer depends greatly both on the pre-existing condition of the fencer, and on which part of the season the training falls into. The following is an attempt at setting some guidelines for a good conditioning program for fencers.

The first and most important point is that a fitness professional should always be consulted before starting a workout plan. When choosing a trainer to work or consult with, it is important that they do some preliminary testing with you, that you ensure that they are aware of any pre-existing conditions that may affect your exercise capacity, and that they discuss your specific strengths and weaknesses with you.

Since many trainers have never seen fencing, it would also be useful to demonstrate some the movements you will be doing (lunge, advance, retreat, etc.)to them and walk them through the phases of each. This will give them a more complete understanding of the muscles used in each movement and the biomechanics involved.

In terms of the workout plan itself, there are a few important points to keep in mind:

  • Any exercise done without proper form has the potential to hurt you, and probably won’t help you.
  • While “bulking up”  should be avoided (no fencer should be aspiring to become an Olympic weightlifter), heavy weights are not necessarily a problem.

Get More Power

Many fencers have problems with power and acceleration, and it is difficult to train these aspects of a movement without applying significant resistance. Bulking up will occur only if a fencer trains exclusively with very heavy weights, and particularly with isolated exercises. If the fencer makes sure to maintain their range of motion, stretch, and to involve multiple joints/muscle groups in their exercises, they should not become “bulky” or slow down.

All fencers, like any competitive athlete, should have a good base of strength and cardiovascular fitness to work from. This implies that if a fencer is just starting a fitness program for the first time, it need not be particularly fencing-specific, and cardiovascular training can be accomplished by simple jogging or running.

In this “basic strength” phase, neither weight nor reps need be high. Focus should initially be on understanding the movements involved in each exercise and performing them correctly, and on training all parts of the body (this includes the dreaded shoulder area). Exercises should involve multiple joints as much as possible, and train the body to work together.

Divide your workout by movement, not muscle group

In addition to weight training, cross training can help develop your speed and agility

I personally divide my workouts into different broad categories of movements (pushing, pulling, jumping, etc.), instead of specific muscles. Some important core exercises to address in the basic strength phase would be squats (often body weight is fine to begin with, focusing on avoiding the knees crossing over the toes), bench press/pushups, and lat pulldown (ideally pull-ups). These three exercises already involve the vast majority of the body’s main muscle groups , and can be easily modified (particularly in the case of the upper body exercises) by simply changing hand placement. They also all involve body stability, which is extremely important in all sports.

Other important exercises include lunges (walking lunges, forward lunges, back lunges, etc.), rows (these assist greatly in keeping the fencer’s back straight in en guarde), and a huge variety of abdominal exercises, both lying down (e.g. sit ups) and standing (e.g. twists with resistance bands).  The frequency in any of these exercises should be two or three sets of 10-12, at about 70% of the fencer’s maximum capacity for each exercise.  Since this phase is to build a base of conditioning, it is more important to get through the sets and repetitions than it is to get to particularly heavy weights (though it is very important to progress and gradually increase the weight).

Seasonality of Your Training

A more advanced athlete should begin considering how to vary his/her workout depending on the phase of the competitive season.

About a month or two before tournaments start, training should start shifting more towards being fencing specific. Cardiovascular fitness should now be steered towards the sort necessary during a bout. This means that running long distances is no longer necessary-interval training, sprints, and jump roping are much more effective and efficient.

 

Jump Rope

Interval training should be done with work/rest ratios similar to a bout. For instance, I will jump rope for three minutes, “rest” by doing basic footwork for a minute, jump for three minutes, and so forth).  For running, I will jog for 2.5 minutes, sprint for 30 seconds, and repeat that cycle. This may vary between the weapons, as the average length of a touch in sabre is much shorter than that in epee. For a sabreist, it may be more useful to sprint/rest at a 5 second sprint/30 second rest ratio. An agility ladder may be incorporated, to increase the fencer’s agility and ability to change direction.

Plyometrics (jumping exercises) are also extremely effective in increasing power and speed, but can also be quite dangerous and can aggravate any previously existing conditions (the most common being patellar tendinitis), so they should be done cautiously and under close supervision. Weightlifting volume should change here as well; weight should start increasing (closer to the fencer’s limit), and repetitions per set need not be as high (this is true particularly of the lower body exercises).

The closer the fencer gets to the competition, the more he/she should focus on lots of power and speed over short periods of time, and the more specific exercises and training should be to fencing movements.

It is important to remember that fencers, like any other athletes, can benefit greatly from a good weightlifting and conditioning program. This should by no means replace the regular bouting, drilling, footwork, lessons, etc. that the fencer normally does. Cross training can also be a fun and effective way to train, particularly sports like squash and badminton that require quick changes in direction and good footwork over small distances.

A good program doesn’t need any complicated, fancy exercises.  It just needs a solid design, needs to be safe and age/skill level appropriate, and has to fit the fencer’s schedule and capacity. Any trainer should be able to design an effective program for a fencer (provided the fencer takes some time to explain how fencing works to them), and any fencer who follows a safe and effective strength and conditioning program should see significant results in their fencing.


Lorenzo Casertano, CSCS (Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist) is a graduate of Columbia University (majoring in neuroscience), and in graduate school at Columbia now getting a Doctorate in Physical Therapy.  Lorenzo is currently a competitive epee fencer representing the NYAC.




Share:

12 Comments

  • Gereg Jones Muller, August 27, 2010 @ 7:44 pm

    Really excellent article. Not only applicable to fencing, I feel this approach would benefit a practitioner of any martial art.

  • Gereg Jones Muller, August 27, 2010 @ 3:44 pm

    Really excellent article. Not only applicable to fencing, I feel this approach would benefit a practitioner of any martial art.

  • Ian, August 31, 2010 @ 6:04 pm

    “Bulking up will occur only if a fencer trains exclusively with very heavy weights, and particularly with isolated exercises.”

    If “bulking” refers to muscular hypertrophy, this statement appears misinformed. Size mainly indicates slow-twitch muscle, which is stimulated by higher rep counts, since fast-twitch fibers fatigue sooner.

    We can see this principle exemplified by comparing bodybuilders to powerlifters. Bodybuilders tend to be bigger but weaker because the focus is on size and shape rather than weight records and single rep ME lifts.

    “If the fencer makes sure to maintain their range of motion, stretch, and to involve multiple joints/muscle groups in their exercises, they should not become ‘bulky’ or slow down.”

    A muscle can either become bigger, smaller, or stay the same. If the subject of a weight training program is correctly performing exercises with resistance (and eating properly), he will grow muscle. However, he’s not going to wake up one day looking like Jay Cutler.

    It’s funny how people are scared of getting bulky, as if it’s easy to do accidentally. It’s unrealistic to believe you can be an Olympic champion without training like one. In the same way, you’re not going to look like a bodybuilder unless you go to the extreme lengths they do.

    “In this ‘basic strength’ phase… Exercises should involve multiple joints as much as possible, and train the body to work together.”

    Exercises with compound movements are form-intensive and difficult to learn properly (like squats or deadlifts). Someone in a basic strength phase likely won’t have the foundation to get the most from these exercises. Their weak stabilizing muscles will fatigue before the intended muscle group will. For someone new to the gym, using the Smith Rack or other machines is useful because it sets the range of motion. Of course, have a certified trainer help you at first; don’t just come into the gym with a copy of Men’s Fitness.

  • Ian, August 31, 2010 @ 2:04 pm

    “Bulking up will occur only if a fencer trains exclusively with very heavy weights, and particularly with isolated exercises.”

    If “bulking” refers to muscular hypertrophy, this statement appears misinformed. Size mainly indicates slow-twitch muscle, which is stimulated by higher rep counts, since fast-twitch fibers fatigue sooner.

    We can see this principle exemplified by comparing bodybuilders to powerlifters. Bodybuilders tend to be bigger but weaker because the focus is on size and shape rather than weight records and single rep ME lifts.

    “If the fencer makes sure to maintain their range of motion, stretch, and to involve multiple joints/muscle groups in their exercises, they should not become ‘bulky’ or slow down.”

    A muscle can either become bigger, smaller, or stay the same. If the subject of a weight training program is correctly performing exercises with resistance (and eating properly), he will grow muscle. However, he’s not going to wake up one day looking like Jay Cutler.

    It’s funny how people are scared of getting bulky, as if it’s easy to do accidentally. It’s unrealistic to believe you can be an Olympic champion without training like one. In the same way, you’re not going to look like a bodybuilder unless you go to the extreme lengths they do.

    “In this ‘basic strength’ phase… Exercises should involve multiple joints as much as possible, and train the body to work together.”

    Exercises with compound movements are form-intensive and difficult to learn properly (like squats or deadlifts). Someone in a basic strength phase likely won’t have the foundation to get the most from these exercises. Their weak stabilizing muscles will fatigue before the intended muscle group will. For someone new to the gym, using the Smith Rack or other machines is useful because it sets the range of motion. Of course, have a certified trainer help you at first; don’t just come into the gym with a copy of Men’s Fitness.

  • Ben, September 7, 2010 @ 12:23 pm

    Five points:

    1) Overall I think this is a good and rather forward thinking article for fencing.

    2) The strength program presented (squat, horizontal push/pull, vertical pull, quad dominant single leg, and anterior core) lacks one major component: the posterior chain. This includes the glutes, hamstrings, and lower back. Squats train the posterior chain, but not to the degree of the deadlift, (power) clean or snatch, and hip thrust (google Bret Contreras hip thrust). Single leg hip dominant exercises might be alternated or added to the quad dominant exercise, e.g. alternate single leg Romanian deadlift with lunges.

    3) Re: Ian, time should be invested in learning compound movements because they give the greatest return, particularly for improving athletic performance. Stabilizing muscles should be trained just as major muscle groups should or the athlete risks injury and lower performance. Long term athletic development is the priority.

    4) ‘While “bulking up” should be avoided (no fencer should be aspiring to become an Olympic weightlifter), heavy weights are not necessarily a problem.’

    I largely agree with this statement, but disagree with the harsh words for Olympic-style weightlifting.

    Olympic weightlifters in the limited weight classes have a tremendous amount of mass-specific force, i.e. the amount of force they can generate relative to their bodyweight. Mass-specific force greatly determines an athlete’s performance across a wide variety of sports, arguably fencing included. Fencers largely depend on the phosphagen metabolic pathway rather than the aerobic or anaerobic during competition, particularly sabre fencers. The phosphagen (explosive) pathway is best developed with strength and power training. Olympic-style weightlifting, i.e. the snatch and the clean and jerk, are terrific ways to develop explosive speed and power.

    5) The movements mentioned above, namely the deadlift, squat, snatch, and clean and jerk are quite technical (particularly the last two) and are best learned with lots of practice under the guidance of a coach. However, one can learn these lifts on their own. U.S. Olympic champion Bill Starr learned the Olympic lifts from carefully observing sequence photos in a book. Resources that I personally recommend include “Starting Strength, 2nd Edition” by Mark Rippetoe and Lon Kilgore and “Olympic Weightlifting” by Greg Everett. These books are a fantastic way to learn the lifts.

  • Ben, September 7, 2010 @ 8:23 am

    Five points:

    1) Overall I think this is a good and rather forward thinking article for fencing.

    2) The strength program presented (squat, horizontal push/pull, vertical pull, quad dominant single leg, and anterior core) lacks one major component: the posterior chain. This includes the glutes, hamstrings, and lower back. Squats train the posterior chain, but not to the degree of the deadlift, (power) clean or snatch, and hip thrust (google Bret Contreras hip thrust). Single leg hip dominant exercises might be alternated or added to the quad dominant exercise, e.g. alternate single leg Romanian deadlift with lunges.

    3) Re: Ian, time should be invested in learning compound movements because they give the greatest return, particularly for improving athletic performance. Stabilizing muscles should be trained just as major muscle groups should or the athlete risks injury and lower performance. Long term athletic development is the priority.

    4) ‘While “bulking up” should be avoided (no fencer should be aspiring to become an Olympic weightlifter), heavy weights are not necessarily a problem.’

    I largely agree with this statement, but disagree with the harsh words for Olympic-style weightlifting.

    Olympic weightlifters in the limited weight classes have a tremendous amount of mass-specific force, i.e. the amount of force they can generate relative to their bodyweight. Mass-specific force greatly determines an athlete’s performance across a wide variety of sports, arguably fencing included. Fencers largely depend on the phosphagen metabolic pathway rather than the aerobic or anaerobic during competition, particularly sabre fencers. The phosphagen (explosive) pathway is best developed with strength and power training. Olympic-style weightlifting, i.e. the snatch and the clean and jerk, are terrific ways to develop explosive speed and power.

    5) The movements mentioned above, namely the deadlift, squat, snatch, and clean and jerk are quite technical (particularly the last two) and are best learned with lots of practice under the guidance of a coach. However, one can learn these lifts on their own. U.S. Olympic champion Bill Starr learned the Olympic lifts from carefully observing sequence photos in a book. Resources that I personally recommend include “Starting Strength, 2nd Edition” by Mark Rippetoe and Lon Kilgore and “Olympic Weightlifting” by Greg Everett. These books are a fantastic way to learn the lifts.

  • guest, September 15, 2010 @ 4:13 am

    Hey, methinks he is not saying anything bad about Olympic lifters, or about the excercises; merely that the ideal held by those athelets, is not -in his (Lorenzo’s) opinion- the correct ideal for fencers to hold.

    With which statement I agree.

  • guest, December 15, 2010 @ 6:24 pm

    i agreed with everything you said up until the smiths. smith machines actually suck; they are a “one size fits all” and no two persons anatomy is the same. for the compound movements, simply train lighter at first to get correct form down then move on to heavier weights. there are NO substitutes for compound exercises.

  • ladyofshalott99, August 12, 2011 @ 7:09 pm

    Craig–I realize you wrote this quite a while ago, and I apologize in advance if this should actually be a separate thread in the forums. But I’ve just now read it and have a few questions, or rather, counter-points, to offer to the article.

    First, this statement:

    “Bulking up will occur only if a fencer trains exclusively with very heavy weights, and particularly with isolated exercises. If the fencer makes sure to maintain their range of motion, stretch, and to involve multiple joints/muscle groups in their exercises, they should not become “bulky” or slow down.”

    There are a few problems with this assertion. One, that “very heavy weights” will “bulk” someone up. You can indeed lift heavy weights, and at the same time, lean out. How much “bulk” someone puts on is dependent on several factors, nutrition being a HUGE contributor. Example: of what we consider the “Elite” athletes at my CrossFit gym, the average woman who successfully completes the “prescribed” weight for a front squat is typically lifting 175#. (I’m more at #135). And they’re all deadlifting their body weight, and then some. They’re (we’re) not all bulging muscles and oiling up for bikini contests. It’s just women leaning out, reducing body fat to 12-18% (8-9% for men), and becoming stronger, fitter humans. We take that, and we input that into whatever else we do. For those who fence, who also lift, this means more stamina, more power, and more strength.   

    Second, in fencing, we tend to see more “lean” individuals, i.e., those who tend to be more of a “dedicated runner” type than a “weight lifter” type. This is just my personal observation, but there seems to be more of a perception that the desired body type is, and should be, individuals who *look* as if they have lean body mass (sorry, Sabre fencers). But at the same time (and I hope this is what your article is really getting at), that *look* without resistance training just leaves you with a skinny frame. Worse, people focus on how much they weigh without really paying attention to what their body composition is, and thus we end up with people who are “skinny fat”. So maybe they can move on the strip, know how to score the touches, but they crash out at some point in DE’s because their opponent, who has that same mental know-how, has been watching their nutrition, has been putting in the time to balance their strength/weight/speed routines, and delivers the results simply by being more fit than the guy who’s only doing the basics, throwing in some running, and doing “light reps” for good measure.

    Here’s a blog post that more thoroughly explains why you’re not going to bulk up if you lift heavy weights. http://www.crossfitsouthbay.com/2011/05/skinny-fat/

    Lastly, for nutrition: Here’s an example of an MMA guy who cleaned up his diet, kept up with his conditioning, and ended up dominating a fight in 7 seconds. He now holds the record for fastest submission ever. http://www.prweb.com/releases/2011/7/prweb8631814.htmhere's the video for it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ICK1qwLKM64

    Cliffs: Lift weights, don’t eat crap food, lean out, and your conditioning will pay off as long as you don’t suck at the mental part of fencing.

  • Craig, August 12, 2011 @ 7:23 pm

    While Fencing.Net published the article, it was written by Lorenzo Casertano.  I’d direct the questions to him as we had a forum thread discussion about this article back when it was published.  The weights that you tossed out for squats are by no means what I would consider “extremely heavy” unless they weigh 100lbs or less.If you read through the entire article you’ll see the holistic approach to the weight training and conditioning cycle that Lorenzo is hinting at.  It gets spelled out better in the Periodization article.

  • ladyofshalott99, August 12, 2011 @ 8:10 pm

    Another post (that I was looking for earlier) on the power of weight lifting. Yes, another CF author, but he makes some good points.

    What your goals should look like if you’re applying them to a sport, or life in general:
    http://www.rwscrossfit.com/Real-Life-Applications.html

  • Alexander Viglakis, July 30, 2012 @ 1:09 pm

    These rep ranges are out of a fitness magazine. I don't know how you manage a degree without learning which energy systems are taxed by which rep ranges. Look up the work of Rippetoe and Kilgore and skip over this article.

Comments are closed.